contract image/svg+xml
Tofutush posted Apr 7, 2024

The Iron Ragdoll Chapter 1 feedback

https://globalcomix.com/c/the-iron-ragdoll

Since chapter 1 of TIR is complete, I wanted some feedback before moving on to chapter 2. Any feedback would be nice!

Zmax posted Apr 13, 2024

Hi, just had quick look over. I'm presuming the target audience are kids. I liked the colors you used. I found it difficult to follow the story because it seems to be in tiny fragments and not a cohesive whole. Maybe that's a kid thing too, short concentration. Characters are pleasant and amusing. I hope it goes well for you.

Tofutush posted Apr 14, 2024

@Zmax thank you for your feedback! I would like to ask why you think the story is not "a cohesive whole"? Because it wans't meant to be that way.

Zmax posted Apr 15, 2024

Hi Tofutush. I only responded above because your post was 6 days old at the time and nobody had responded. I thought that was pretty sad. We're supposed to be a community, but it seemed no one could be bothered, so I had a look. Your stuff is outside my scope of work so I'm not a good judge of your stuff. About being a cohesive whole, it's just that you've got a lot of releases about 5 pages each, one is even just 1 page from memory. In my line of thinking, my sort of work, I'd join them all together as one release of like 25 to 35 pages, a cohesive whole, so the reader gets a full chapter or episode or what ever you want to call it, instead of little fragmented pieces. That's all. I hope you didn't get upset about it. There was no harm intended. All the best to you. Cheers.